Huge Island Getaway Pool HotTub Walk To Beach Entire home · 6 bedrooms Rated 4.94 - Revenue
- $482,583
- Occupancy
- 58.9%
- Daily rate
- $1,714
Airbnb market data · 202612 months to October 2026
The average Airbnb in Town of Shelter Island brought in $52,928 over the 12 months through October 2026, about 45% more than the New York State average of $36,572.
The short answer
Town of Shelter Island earns on price rather than volume. Listings averaged $779 a night and were booked on 34% of available nights, against $380 and 40% for the New York State average.
Timing matters: in August, usually the best month, the average listing earns about 6 times as much as in January, usually the slowest.
With 95 active listings, Town of Shelter Island is the 75th-largest of 509 New York State markets AirROI tracks. From a year earlier, average revenue rose 9% while the number of active listings shrank 11%.
Browse the live Town of Shelter Island Airbnb market See Every Town of Shelter Island ListingRevenue
Gross bookings per Town of Shelter Island listing averaged $52,928 over the 12 months to October 2026 (New York State average: $36,572), before cleaning, platform and management costs and taxes.
In a typical year, the average Town of Shelter Island listing brings in $18,500 in August, its best month, and $3,110 in January, its slowest. February runs within 2% of January, so either can be the slowest in a given year. The three strongest months bring in 51% of a full year's revenue, where an even calendar would give any three months 25%.
In a typical month, a top-quarter listing earns at least 4.2 times as much as a bottom-quarter one.
These are monthly figures for listings active in each month. The annual average above also counts listings that operated for only part of the year, so it runs below twelve times these figures.
August earns about 6 times what January does
Average revenue per active listing, by month, October 2024 to September 2026
Each point is one month as recorded, averaged over the listings active in it. The best and slowest months in the text average each calendar month over the past two years, so they can differ from the highest and lowest points here.
Latest 12 months in the October 2026 data. October's figures are still coming in, so the rows run to September.
August 2026 led on revenue, nightly rate and bookings alike.
| Month | Avg. Revenue | Occupancy | Avg. Nightly Rate | RevPAR | Booking Lead Time | Avg. Length of Stay |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 2025 | $4,748 | 21.2% | $816 | $153 | 87 days | 3.7 nights |
| Nov 2025 | $5,983 | 33.2% | $804 | $199 | 63 days | 3.8 nights |
| Dec 2025 | $4,572 | 18.7% | $794 | $147 | 36 days | 3.2 nights |
| Jan 2026 | $2,937 | 13.5% | $802 | $95 | 23 days | 3.6 nights |
| Feb 2026 | $3,068 | 17.3% | $803 | $110 | 6 days | 2.9 nights |
| Mar 2026 | $2,824 | 14.9% | $799 | $91 | 3 days | 2.4 nights |
| Apr 2026 | $3,526 | 16.4% | $813 | $118 | 28 days | 5.5 nights |
| May 2026 | $7,528 | 30.2% | $858 | $243 | 58 days | 5.1 nights |
| Jun 2026 | $10,998 | 40.7% | $909 | $367 | 90 days | 4.6 nights |
| Jul 2026 | $18,492 | 60.2% | $938 | $597 | 89 days | 6.7 nights |
| Aug 2026 | $18,517 | 61.0% | $940 | $597 | 110 days | 6.8 nights |
| Sep 2026 | $9,157 | 39.7% | $860 | $305 | 102 days | 2.8 nights |
Averages per active listing in each month. Highlighted: the highest-revenue month of the 12. RevPAR is the month's revenue spread over its nights, booked or not. Booking lead time is the days between booking and check-in, and length of stay the nights per booking, for stays in that month.
These are market-wide figures. To see what one particular Town of Shelter Island home could earn, enter its address, bedrooms and guests in the Airbnb income calculator; it compares the home with similar listings nearby.
Profit
Yes, when it's run well. The average Town of Shelter Island Airbnb took in $52,928 in the 12 months to October 2026, and run by its owner at everyday costs, about $3,040 a month of that is left after running costs, so a home that costs less than that to own or rent makes money. A listing in the top quarter leaves about $5,710 a month.
Cleaning it yourself keeps the $3,600 a year guests pay in cleaning fees, for about $3,340 a month. Handing the listing to a co-host at about 10% of nightly bookings still leaves about $2,620 a month.
These amounts come before housing costs. Where the mortgage or rent is less each month, the difference is profit; a home owned outright keeps it all after property tax, home insurance and any HOA or condo fees.
| Line | Average listing | Top-quarter listing |
|---|---|---|
| Money in | ||
| Nightly bookings | $49,328 | $91,780 |
| Cleaning fees guests pay7% of Town of Shelter Island bookings | $3,600 | $6,690 |
| Gross bookings | $52,928 | $98,470 |
| Running costs | ||
| Airbnb's feeAbout 13%: 15.5% for the 79% of Town of Shelter Island listings on Simplified Pricing, 3% for the rest | −$6,810 | −$12,670 |
| Cleaning and laundryPaid for by the cleaning fee; $0 if you clean yourself | −$3,600 | −$6,690 |
| Utilities and internetAbout 5% of bookings | −$2,650 | −$4,920 |
| Guest suppliesToiletries, coffee, paper goods: about 2% | −$1,060 | −$1,970 |
| Repairs and upkeepIncluding linens and small replacements: about 3% | −$1,590 | −$2,950 |
| Short-term rental insuranceOne policy, on top of Airbnb's free AirCover | −$530 | −$530 |
| Permit and registrationWhere one is required | −$260 | −$260 |
| Management$0 when you run it; co-hosts charge from about 10% of nightly bookings | $0 | $0 |
| Pricing and messaging toolsOptional; Airbnb's own tools are free | $0 | $0 |
| Lodging taxesAdded to the guest's bill and passed on | $0 | $0 |
| Total running costsAbout 24% of bookings, plus cleaning paid for by the cleaning fee | −$16,500 | −$29,990 |
| Left for housing costs, then profit | $36,428about $3,040 a month | $68,480about $5,710 a month |
| Housing costs | ||
| Mortgage or rent, property tax, home insurance, HOA or condo fees | Depend on the home | |
The estimate starts from Town of Shelter Island's average listing, run by its owner. Change how the listing performs, who runs it and who cleans to see what is left for the mortgage or rent.
To work out the profit on one Town of Shelter Island home, with its price, its mortgage or rent and your own costs, use the Airbnb profit calculator. It starts from the comparable listings around the address.
What a listing keeps comes down to the figures this page measures: nightly rate, nights booked and the months it's open. A listing at the top-quarter mark takes in about $8,210 a month, against $4,410 for the average one.
Occupancy
Town of Shelter Island listings were booked on 34% of the nights they were open over the past year, 6 percentage points below the New York State average (40%) and 7 points below the U.S. average (41%). In a typical year, occupancy swings from 15% in January to 62% in August.
The busiest tenth of listings are booked about 4.1 times as often as the bottom quarter.
August is usually the busiest month in Town of Shelter Island, January the quietest
Share of open nights booked, by month, October 2024 to September 2026
The 12-month rate of 34% averages each listing's whole year, slow months included; each month here counts only the listings booked in it.
Nightly rates
The average nightly rate in Town of Shelter Island, known as ADR (average daily rate), was $779 over the past year, about twice the New York State average of $380 and about 2.3 times the U.S. average of $335. In a typical year, rates peak in July and August at about $915 and bottom out in January and December at about $760.
Prices span a wide range: the top 10% charge about 3.3 times the rate of the bottom quarter.
August rates run 21% above December's
Average nightly rate (ADR), by month, October 2024 to September 2026
RevPAR, or revenue per available night, divides a listing's income by every night it was open to book, so it rises with both price and bookings. In Town of Shelter Island it averaged $295 over the past year, from about $100 in a typical January to about $598 in a typical August.
Per open night, by tier:
August RevPAR is about 6 times January's
Revenue per open night (RevPAR), by month, October 2024 to September 2026
The 12-month RevPAR of $295 averages each listing's whole year, slow months included; each month here counts only the listings booked in it.
Seasonality
Town of Shelter Island has one high season, June through September, which makes it a highly seasonal market. Business is slowest from October to April. A listing earns about 4.5 times as much a month in June through August as in December through February.
Average revenue by month in Town of Shelter Island
Average revenue per active listing, each calendar month averaged over the past two years
| Month | Season | Revenue per listing |
|---|---|---|
| January | Low season | $3,110 |
| February | Low season | $3,150 |
| March | Low season | $3,440 |
| April | Low season | $3,810 |
| May | Shoulder season | $7,150 |
| June | High season | $10,400 |
| July | High season | $17,400 |
| August | High season | $18,500 |
| September | High season | $9,080 |
| October | Low season | $5,200 |
| November | Low season | $5,010 |
| December | Low season | $4,100 |
| Season | Revenue per month | Occupancy | Nightly rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| High seasonJune–September | $13,800 | 48% | $892 |
| Shoulder seasonMay | $7,150 | 28% | $834 |
| Low seasonOctober–April | $3,970 | 20% | $771 |
Guests book Town of Shelter Island stays 78 days ahead on average (about two and a half months), so guests here plan well ahead. August stays are booked furthest out, about 115 days ahead, and March stays closest to arrival, about 4 days. A typical August booking is made in late April.
August stays are booked furthest ahead
Average days between booking and check-in, by month of stay, October 2024 to September 2026
The 12-month figure of 78 days averages each listing's year as a whole; each month here averages only the listings with stays in it.
Permits
None of the 95 active listings in Town of Shelter Island display a registration, permit or license number. That doesn't mean no rules apply: some places don't ask hosts to show a number on the listing, and listing data doesn't capture every scheme.
Registration, permit, zoning and occupancy-tax rules vary by address and change often, so confirm them with the city or county before buying or listing in Town of Shelter Island.
Neighborhoods
AirROI's area guide picks eight Town of Shelter Island neighborhoods that draw short-term rental guests, led by Shelter Island Heights, Dering Harbor and Council Hill. The picks reflect guest appeal, not earnings data or permit eligibility, so check local permit rules for a specific address before buying.
| Area | Who it suits | Landmarks nearby |
|---|---|---|
| Shelter Island Heights | A picturesque hamlet that offers beautiful views of the surrounding waters and access to the beach. Popular for its quaint shops and restaurants, it's ideal for family getaways. | Shelter Island Historical Society, Sunset Beach, Shelter Island Yacht Club, Wades Beach, Shelter Island Pavilion |
| Dering Harbor | Known for its luxury homes and exclusivity, Dering Harbor is perfect for those seeking a high-end retreat. It provides a serene atmosphere and stunning waterfront views. | Dering Harbor Marina, Private beaches, Apiary on Shelter Island, East End Seaport Museum |
| Council Hill | This area offers a relaxing environment and is perfect for outdoor enthusiasts. Visitors can enjoy hiking, biking, and exploring nature, making it suitable for active travelers. | Mashomack Preserve, Hubble's Beach, Shell Beach, Nature trails |
| West Neck | West Neck is a quiet neighborhood with a laid-back vibe, ideal for guests looking for a peaceful retreat. Close proximity to beaches and nature makes it an attractive option. | West Neck Beach, Crescent Beach, Bird watching, Fishing spots |
| Silver Beach | A family-friendly area known for its sandy beaches and beachside amenities. It attracts families and groups looking to enjoy the sun and water activities together. | Silver Beach Park, Kayaking, Picnic areas, Swimming spots |
| East Farm | An area with agricultural charm, East Farm offers a unique experience for those looking to explore the countryside. Guests can enjoy farm tours and fresh produce. | Local farms, Farmers markets, Cycling routes, Nature walks |
| Chadwick Beach | A wonderful beachside location that draws visitors for its relaxing atmosphere. It's perfect for summer vacations and beach parties. | Chadwick Beach, Water sports, Beach volleyball, Barbecues |
| Hay Beach | A tranquil and picturesque spot ideal for quiet vacations. Great for nature lovers and those wanting to escape the busyness of city life. | Hay Beach Park, Kayaking opportunities, Nature trails, Wildlife watching |
Area descriptions are AI-assisted from public sources and are not checked against zoning.
Listings
Entire homes make up 83% of listings in Town of Shelter Island, alongside 16 private-room listings (17%). Houses account for 81% of the stock; hotels, guesthouses and B&Bs come next at 15%.
Mostly entire homes, with a private-room segment
Town of Shelter Island Airbnb listings by room type
| Room type | Share of listings | Listings |
|---|---|---|
| Entire home | 83.2% | 79 |
| Private room | 16.8% | 16 |
Houses dominate the property mix
Town of Shelter Island Airbnb listings by property type
| Property type | Share of listings | Listings |
|---|---|---|
| House | 81.1% | 77 |
| Hotel/Boutique | 14.7% | 14 |
| Apartment/Condo | 3.2% | 3 |
| Others | 1.1% | 1 |
Most Town of Shelter Island homes are built for groups: 80% of entire homes have three or more bedrooms, and three-bedroom homes are the most common size (34%). Shares are of the 79 entire homes that give a bedroom count; rented rooms are left out.
Town of Shelter Island entire homes by number of bedrooms
Entire homes with each number of bedrooms, of those with a bedroom count on file
| Bedrooms | Share of entire homes with a bedroom count | Entire homes |
|---|---|---|
| Studio | 1.3% | 1 |
| 1 bedroom | 7.6% | 6 |
| 2 bedrooms | 11.4% | 9 |
| 3 bedrooms | 34.2% | 27 |
| 4 bedrooms | 29.1% | 23 |
| 5+ bedrooms | 16.5% | 13 |
A typical three-bedroom home in Town of Shelter Island earned $49,000 over the past year, against $32,700 for a home with five or more bedrooms.
| Home size | Listings | Typical annual revenue (median) | Average annual revenue | Avg. nightly rate | Occupancy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 bedrooms | 27 | $49,000 | $57,000 | $750 | 38% |
| 4 bedrooms | 23 | $70,100 | $70,900 | $998 | 36% |
| 5+ bedrooms | 13 | $32,700 | $90,300 | $1,246 | 29% |
Town of Shelter Island is a group-trip market: 43% of listings sleep eight or more guests, about 1.6 times the share of the next most common size, six guests (27%). Shares are of the 79 listings with a guest capacity on file (83% of the market).
Town of Shelter Island listings by guest capacity
Share of listings by the number of guests they sleep, of those with a capacity on file
| Guest capacity | Share of listings with a capacity on file | Listings |
|---|---|---|
| 2 guests | 6.3% | 5 |
| 3 guests | 1.3% | 1 |
| 4 guests | 12.7% | 10 |
| 5 guests | 3.8% | 3 |
| 6 guests | 26.6% | 21 |
| 7 guests | 6.3% | 5 |
| 8+ guests | 43.0% | 34 |
Town of Shelter Island hosts set up an average of 3.9 beds per listing, close to one bed per bedroom. Only 12% of listings show their exact location on the listing map; the rest show an approximate area.
Free on-site parking is close to standard in Town of Shelter Island: 97% of listings offer it, and 76% have a barbecue grill.
Share of Town of Shelter Island listings with each common amenity
Guests
Town of Shelter Island draws mostly domestic guests: 93% of those who left reviews live in the United States. New York alone accounts for 43% of reviews. Of the 7% from abroad, the largest groups come from the United Kingdom and Switzerland. English is spoken by 60% of guests, and Spanish by 17%.
93% of Town of Shelter Island guests are domestic
Where guests who left reviews live
Where Town of Shelter Island guests come from: top cities
Share of guests who left reviews
| Origin city | Share of guests |
|---|---|
| New York | 42.9% |
| Boston | 2.0% |
| Los Angeles | 2.0% |
| Philadelphia | 1.4% |
| Port Washington | 1.4% |
Where Town of Shelter Island guests come from: top countries
Share of guests who left reviews
| Origin country | Share of guests |
|---|---|
| United States | 93.2% |
| United Kingdom | 2.0% |
| Switzerland | 0.6% |
| Mexico | 0.6% |
Languages spoken by Town of Shelter Island guests
Share of guests who left reviews
| Language | Share of guests |
|---|---|
| English | 60.2% |
| Spanish | 16.8% |
| French | 8.7% |
| Russian | 1.9% |
| Portuguese | 1.2% |
Town of Shelter Island Airbnbs average 4.91 stars, and 58% of listings hold Airbnb's Guest Favorite badge.
Town of Shelter Island guest ratings by category
Average guest rating out of 5 by category; the bars start at 4.0
| Category | Average rating (out of 5) |
|---|---|
| Accuracy | 4.92 |
| Cleanliness | 4.87 |
| Communication | 4.96 |
| Location | 4.96 |
| Check-in | 4.96 |
| Value | 4.79 |
Booking patterns
Nearly all Town of Shelter Island listings are open to guests more than 180 days a year, but only 3% are booked or blocked that many days. The most common booked-or-blocked total is 31 to 90 days a year, covering 37% of listings; blocked nights include any the host closes off.
Days a year Town of Shelter Island listings are open to guests
Share of listings by days a year
| Days a year | Share of listings | Listings |
|---|---|---|
| 271-366 days | 71.6% | 68 |
| 181-270 days | 25.3% | 24 |
| 91-180 days | 3.2% | 3 |
Days a year Town of Shelter Island listings are booked or blocked
Share of listings by days a year
| Days a year | Share of listings | Listings |
|---|---|---|
| 181-270 days | 3.2% | 3 |
| 91-180 days | 25.3% | 24 |
| 31-90 days | 36.8% | 35 |
| 1-30 days | 34.7% | 33 |
The average Town of Shelter Island booking lasts 5.1 nights, longest in August and shortest in March. Listings took about 13 bookings each over the year, some 1,200 in all. More than four in ten listings that give a check-in time set it at 4 p.m., with check-out usually at 11 a.m.
Average length of stay by month in Town of Shelter Island
Average nights per booking, by month of stay
Two-year average by calendar month.
40% of listings in Town of Shelter Island accept stays of one or two nights; the most common minimum is two nights.
Minimum stay set by Town of Shelter Island listings
Share of listings by the shortest stay they accept, from one night to 30 or more
Firm is the most common cancellation policy in Town of Shelter Island, used by 60% of listings; it refunds guests in full only if they cancel at least 30 days before check-in. Hosts here lean strict: more than eight in ten listings use Firm or stricter terms, against 18% on Flexible or Moderate.
Cancellation policies of Town of Shelter Island listings, from most to least flexible
Share of listings by the policy they use
Nearly nine in ten Town of Shelter Island listings charge a cleaning fee. The typical fee is about $287. Spread over the average stay of 5.1 nights, that adds roughly $55 a night to what guests pay. For listings that charge one, cleaning fees make up about 7% of gross revenue.
Top earners
The top-grossing Airbnb in Town of Shelter Island, a six-bedroom home, took in $483,000 over the past year, about 9.1 times the city's average of $52,900.
Huge Island Getaway Pool HotTub Walk To Beach Entire home · 6 bedrooms Rated 4.94
Family Friendly Oasis Steps to Water - Heated Pool Entire home · 6 bedrooms Rated 5.00
Private Hay Beach Retreat with Heated Pool Entire home · 4 bedrooms Rated 4.98
Waterfront Treehouse with Pool as seen on HBO Entire home · 4 bedrooms Rated 5.00
Scandinavian family home on the water Entire home · 3 bedrooms Rated 4.88
Shelter Island home with pool Entire home · 4 bedrooms Rated 4.96 Only 4% of Town of Shelter Island listings are classed as professionally managed. Superhosts run 32% of listings. Most hosts still vet their guests: only 9% of listings accept Instant Book. Airbnb's Simplified Pricing, where the host pays the whole service fee and guests see one price with no separate Airbnb charge, covers 79% of listings.
Nearby markets
Of the eight nearby markets in the table, all within 26 km, Sag Harbor (9 km away, 46 listings) earned the most per listing, about 83% more than Town of Shelter Island. Westbrook was the busiest, booked on 41% of nights against 34% in Town of Shelter Island.
| Market | Listings | Avg. annual revenue | Avg. nightly rate | Occupancy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Greenport 5 km | 31 | $64,782 | $808 | 34% |
| Town of Southold 7 km | 423 | $58,968 | $721 | 35% |
| Sag Harbor 9 km | 46 | $96,933 | $1,217 | 39% |
| Town of East Hampton 21 km | 1,191 | $71,684 | $1,067 | 34% |
| Town of Southampton 21 km | 1,101 | $69,210 | $1,106 | 33% |
| Old Saybrook 24 km | 69 | $38,168 | $487 | 36% |
| Westbrook 26 km | 67 | $43,081 | $440 | 41% |
| Hampton Bays 26 km | 54 | $74,606 | $858 | 35% |
See all 509 New York Airbnb markets
Markets elsewhere in the United States with a similar nightly rate and occupancy to Town of Shelter Island:
FAQ
An active Town of Shelter Island Airbnb grossed $52,928 on average in the 12 months to October 2026, according to AirROI's tracking of 95 active listings. That is before cleaning, management, taxes and financing. Busier, better-run listings do far better: the top quarter took in $10,200 or more in a typical month.
It depends most on the home's size, location and how it's run. The middle half of Town of Shelter Island listings earn between $2,400 and $10,200 in a typical month, and the top tenth $17,300 or more. For one home, enter its address and bedroom count in the Airbnb calculator: it compares the home with similar listings nearby.
Listings in Town of Shelter Island were booked on 34% of available nights over the past year. That compares with 40% for the New York State average. August is usually the busiest month.
The average booked night in Town of Shelter Island cost $779 before fees. Half of listings charge between $440 and $1,045, so bedroom count and location move the price more than the average suggests.
None of the active Town of Shelter Island listings display a registration, permit or license number. That doesn't mean no rules apply, so confirm registration, permit and occupancy-tax rules with the city or county before buying.
Yes, when it's run well. The average Town of Shelter Island Airbnb grossed $52,928 in the 12 months to October 2026, 45% above the New York State average of $36,572. Run by its owner, with the cleaning fee covering the cleaner and everyday costs for Airbnb's fee, utilities, supplies, upkeep and insurance, $36,428 a year (about $3,040 a month) is left before the mortgage or rent. A home that costs less than that to own or rent makes a profit, and a listing at the top-quarter mark leaves about $5,710 a month. Check a specific home in the Airbnb estimator.
August usually pays best, averaging $18,500 per active listing over the past two years, and January usually pays least. The month-by-month table above shows how the latest 12 months played out.
Each night a Town of Shelter Island listing was open to book earned $295 on average over the past year, booked or not. That figure, revenue per available night (RevPAR), folds price and occupancy into one number; the top 10% of listings made $607 or more.
Town of Shelter Island stays were booked 78 days (about two and a half months) before arrival on average over the past year, so a listing that opens its calendar late misses many bookings.
The average Town of Shelter Island Airbnb stay lasted 5.1 nights over the past year. A listing took 13 reservations over the year on average.
Guests rate Town of Shelter Island Airbnbs 4.91 out of 5 on average. Guests score communication highest and value lowest.
Shelter Island Heights, Dering Harbor and Council Hill draw the most short-term rental interest in Town of Shelter Island. The neighborhood guide explains what brings guests to each.
AirROI counted 95 active Airbnb listings in Town of Shelter Island as of October 2026. The closest tracked market is Greenport, 5 km away.
In Town of Shelter Island, nearly nine in ten listings add a cleaning fee, and the typical fee is about $287.
All of New York had 321.2 million visitors in 2025, Empire State Development reports. AirROI estimates 1,197 Airbnb stays in Town of Shelter Island, NY in the 12 months to October 2026, which counts bookings and not tourists. See New York tourism statistics.
Method
Figures on this page cover 95 active Airbnb listings in Town of Shelter Island from November 2025 to October 2026 (trailing twelve months). AirROI refreshes them monthly from listing-level booking and calendar data covering 20+ million properties worldwide. Money figures are in U.S. dollars. Annual revenue averages every listing active during the period, including those listed for only part of it; monthly figures average the listings active in each month; the tier lists show the spread. Neighborhood descriptions are AI-assisted. See the methodology for definitions.
Need this programmatically? The same metrics are available through the AirROI Airbnb Data API and bulk downloads in the data portal.