AirROI ranking · 202612 companies ranked

Best Airbnb Management Companies in Indianapolis (2026)

Source: AirROI Reviewed by , Founder @ AirROI

The short answer

Indianapolis Airbnb Management in Brief

Company-run Indianapolis homes out-earn similar owner-run ones by 14%.

In the 12 months to September 2026, Indianapolis's largest Airbnb and vacation rental management company was CozySuites, with 161 of the city's 2,990 active Airbnb listings; LiveSuites was next with 46. In all, 12 companies ran five or more Indianapolis listings.

"Similar owner-run homes" are homes whose owner runs only that one Indianapolis listing, with no co-host, the same bedrooms and room type, listed all year and open on 240+ nights, booked on 60+ of them, with 5+ reviews. Revenue is what each home earned on Airbnb, estimated from booked nights and rates; stays sold on other sites or direct aren't counted.

Revenue, occupancy and nightly rates across the whole market are in the Indianapolis Airbnb market report .

The ranking

Indianapolis Airbnb Management Companies, Ranked

Companies are ranked by the active Indianapolis listings they run, as host or as co-host on an owner's account. "Lead vs similar" shows how much more a company's homes earned than owner-run Indianapolis homes with the same number of bedrooms and room type, where they earned more, so a company of big houses isn't flattered by their size.

Of the 6 top-ranked companies that host mainly on their own accounts and had listings a year ago, 5 grew over the past year.

Largest management companies in Indianapolis

Ranked by active Indianapolis listings run as host or co-host in the 12 months to September 2026.

Largest management companies in Indianapolis
#CompanyListings
CozySuites+36 in a yearZIP 46204 · ZIP 46282★ 4.62 · +8% vs similar homes161
LiveSuitesZIP 46204 · ZIP 46206★ 4.70 · +56% vs similar homes46
EvolveZIP 46206 · ZIP 46201★ 4.72 · +5% vs similar homes44
4Lazy Sunday RentalsZIP 46225 · ZIP 46205★ 4.8918
5MGM PropertiesZIP 46282 · ZIP 46250★ 4.5516
6Ayash HospitalityCo-hosts · ZIP 46202 · ZIP 46240★ 4.698
7Hosted by The Webers TeamCo-hosts · ZIP 46225 · ZIP 46208★ 4.948
8LuxieStaysZIP 46282 · ZIP 46208★ 4.938
9Serenity HousingCo-hosts★ 4.887
10Grand Slam Getaways★ 4.746
11RoomPicks★ 4.666
12Legendary Five Star GetawaysZIP 46203 · ZIP 46227★ 4.595

Fastest-growing management companies in Indianapolis

Listings added over the past 12 months on each company's own Airbnb accounts, among companies running at least 10 today. Companies that mostly co-host on owners' accounts are left out, because Airbnb's co-host records from a year ago are incomplete.

Fastest-growing management companies in Indianapolis
#CompanyListings added
CozySuitesZIP 46204 · ZIP 46282★ 4.62 · +8% vs similar homes+36
LiveSuitesZIP 46204 · ZIP 46206★ 4.70 · +56% vs similar homes+9
EvolveZIP 46206 · ZIP 46201★ 4.72 · +5% vs similar homes+7

Best-rated Airbnb management companies in Indianapolis

Average guest rating across each company's rated listings, weighted by reviews, among companies with at least 10 rated listings and 100 reviews.

Best-rated Airbnb management companies in Indianapolis
#CompanyAverage rating
Lazy Sunday RentalsZIP 46225 · ZIP 46205★ 4.894.89
EvolveZIP 46206 · ZIP 46201★ 4.72 · +5% vs similar homes4.72
LiveSuitesZIP 46204 · ZIP 46206★ 4.70 · +56% vs similar homes4.70
4CozySuitesZIP 46204 · ZIP 46282★ 4.62 · +8% vs similar homes4.62
5MGM PropertiesZIP 46282 · ZIP 46250★ 4.554.55

Management companies whose homes most out-earn similar Indianapolis listings

Each company's year-round homes against owner-run Indianapolis homes with the same bedrooms and room type, among companies with at least 15 such homes.

Management companies whose homes most out-earn similar Indianapolis listings
#CompanyLead vs similar
LiveSuitesZIP 46204 · ZIP 46206★ 4.70 · +56% vs similar homes+56%
CozySuitesZIP 46204 · ZIP 46282★ 4.62 · +8% vs similar homes+8%
EvolveZIP 46206 · ZIP 46201★ 4.72 · +5% vs similar homes+5%
How to read this table

Shortlist

The Best Airbnb Management Companies in Indianapolis, by Home Size

A company that runs studios well may not suit a four-bedroom house. For each size, these are the Indianapolis companies whose homes of that size out-earn owner-run homes of the same size by enough to cover a 20% fee (25% or more), on at least five year-round homes of that size, rated 4.7 or higher over 100 or more reviews. Leads of 150% or more are left out: that's more than management usually explains.

Studios and 1 bedroom

  1. LiveSuites 13 homes · rated 4.70
    +37%

2 bedrooms

  1. LiveSuites 14 homes · rated 4.70
    +98%

3 bedrooms

  1. Lazy Sunday Rentals 5 homes · rated 4.89 · small sample
    +74%

4 bedrooms or more

No company yet has enough highly rated year-round 4+ bedroom homes with a 25% lead to list here; the ranking above covers every company.

Each figure is revenue against owner-run homes with the same bedrooms and room type, on the company's year-round homes of that size only. "Small sample" marks a figure on five to nine homes: a lead to follow up, not a result. It says what the company's homes earned, not what yours will.

Fees

What an Airbnb Manager Costs in Indianapolis

Few management companies publish their fees. Of the 81 companies AirROI checked in 6 US cities in September 2026, 9 publish a rate, from 10% to 30% of booking revenue with a median starting rate of 15%, and 49 quote only on request. Expect to ask each Indianapolis company you shortlist for a quote.

Get the rate in writing along with what it's charged on: some companies take their share of the nightly rate only, others of everything the guest pays, cleaning fee included. With the company-run median Indianapolis cleaning fee of $115, a 20% rate that also applies to cleaning takes another $23 from every stay. Ask too what's billed on top (linen, repairs, a setup fee) and how much notice ends the contract.

At the median starting rate, rounded to 15%, a manager has to lift revenue by 18% to leave an owner where they started, and 49% of company-run Indianapolis homes earned at least that much more than the owner-run median for their size.

What a fee costs a year on a median Indianapolis home

What a fee costs a year on a median Indianapolis home
HomeMedian revenue15% fee20% fee25% fee30% fee
1 bedroom$20,100$3,015$4,020$5,025$6,030
2 bedrooms$26,900$4,035$5,380$6,725$8,070
3 bedrooms$31,400$4,710$6,280$7,850$9,420
4 bedrooms$47,600$7,140$9,520$11,900$14,280
5+ bedrooms$78,500$11,775$15,700$19,625$23,550

The fee on the median booking revenue of entire homes listed all 12 months, at common rates. A company's quote for your home can differ; ask for the full rate card in writing.

The numbers

Is an Airbnb Manager Worth It in Indianapolis?

Across Indianapolis, listings run by companies earned 14% more than owner-run listings with the same number of bedrooms and room type over the 12 months to September 2026, with nightly rates 16% higher.

A company charging a share of revenue pays for itself on revenue alone when it lifts income by more than the share: a 20% fee needs a 25% lift. The table shows how many company-run homes clear each bar:

Company-run homes that earn enough to cover each fee

  • Company-run
  • Owner-run
  • 15% fee needs +18% 49%
  • 20% fee needs +25% 46%
  • 25% fee needs +33% 43%
  • 30% fee needs +43% 37%
  • 35% fee needs +54% 30%

A home "earns it" when its revenue over the 12 months to September 2026 beat the owner-run median for homes of the same room type and bedroom count by at least the lift shown. Homes listed all year only.

How we compared

Read the 20% row. 46% of company-run Indianapolis homes earned at least 25% more than the owner-run median for their size, enough to pay that fee and still leave the owner ahead. 33% of owner-run homes cleared the same mark with no manager at all, so a company-run home is 13 percentage points more likely to clear the bar, beyond the ±10 points that chance alone could produce on these numbers. Ask any manager to show you homes of its own that clear it.

Results vary by company, and the ranking shows the companies whose homes lead similar ones. Managers also choose the homes they take on, so part of any lead reflects the homes, and the comparison matches homes by room type and bedrooms only, not by street or finish. It counts Airbnb bookings only.

Profiles

The 10 Top-Ranked Companies, Profiled

The 10 top-ranked companies: what each runs, where, and how its homes compare with similar owner-run Indianapolis homes. Each card's revenue, per-night and nights figures are medians across its homes, so the last two don't multiply to the first.

The six top-ranked

  • CozySuites

    #1 by listings ZIP 46204, ZIP 46282

    Largest in Indianapolis Out-earns similar owner-run homes

    CozySuites is Indianapolis's largest Airbnb management company, with 161 active listings.

    Active listings
    161
    +36 in a year
    Guest rating
    4.62
    4,530 reviews
    Nightly rate
    $170
    median
    vs similar homes
    +8%
    revenue, 110 homes compared
    What it runs
    Results
    Account
    CozySuites in figures
  • LiveSuites

    #2 by listings ZIP 46204, ZIP 46206

    Best results in Indianapolis Out-earns similar homes by enough to cover a 20% fee

    LiveSuites is Indianapolis's 2nd largest Airbnb management company, with 46 active listings, and guests rate its homes 4.70 over 1,890 reviews.

    Active listings
    46
    +9 in a year
    Guest rating
    4.70
    1,890 reviews
    Nightly rate
    $185
    median
    vs similar homes
    +56%
    revenue, 29 homes compared
    What it runs
    Results
    Account
    LiveSuites in figures
  • Evolve

    #3 by listings ZIP 46206, ZIP 46201

    Out-earns similar owner-run homes

    Evolve is Indianapolis's 3rd largest Airbnb management company, with 44 active listings, and guests rate its homes 4.72 over 835 reviews.

    Active listings
    44
    +7 in a year
    Guest rating
    4.72
    835 reviews
    Nightly rate
    $240
    median
    vs similar homes
    +5%
    revenue, 16 homes compared
    What it runs
    Results
    Account
    Evolve in figures
  • 4

    Lazy Sunday Rentals

    #4 by listings ZIP 46225, ZIP 46205

    Best rated in Indianapolis

    Lazy Sunday Rentals runs 18 active Indianapolis Airbnb listings, and guests rate its homes 4.89 over 608 reviews.

    Active listings
    18
    +2 in a year
    Guest rating
    4.89
    608 reviews
    Nightly rate
    $240
    median
    Year-round homes
    6
    listed all 12 months
    What it runs
    Results
    Account
    Lazy Sunday Rentals in figures
  • 5

    MGM Properties

    #5 by listings ZIP 46282, ZIP 46250

    MGM Properties runs 16 active Indianapolis Airbnb listings.

    Active listings
    16
    Nightly rate
    $165
    median
    Year-round homes
    2
    listed all 12 months
    What it runs
    Account
    MGM Properties in figures
  • 6

    Ayash Hospitality

    #6 by listings ZIP 46202, ZIP 46240 Co-hosts on owners' accounts

    Ayash Hospitality runs 8 active Indianapolis Airbnb listings.

    Active listings
    8
    Guest rating
    4.69
    448 reviews
    Nightly rate
    $210
    median
    Year-round homes
    4
    listed all 12 months
    What it runs
    Account
    Ayash Hospitality in figures

The next ranked

  • 7

    Hosted by The Webers Team

    #7 by listings ZIP 46225, ZIP 46208 Co-hosts on owners' accounts

    Hosted by The Webers Team runs 8 active Indianapolis Airbnb listings, and guests rate its homes 4.94 over 469 reviews.

    Active listings
    8
    Guest rating
    4.94
    469 reviews
    Nightly rate
    $325
    median
    Year-round homes
    5
    listed all 12 months
    What it runs
    Results
    Account
    Hosted by The Webers Team in figures
  • 8

    LuxieStays

    #8 by listings ZIP 46282, ZIP 46208

    LuxieStays runs 8 active Indianapolis Airbnb listings, and guests rate its homes 4.93 over 1,420 reviews.

    Active listings
    8
    +3 in a year
    Guest rating
    4.93
    1,420 reviews
    Nightly rate
    $260
    median
    Year-round homes
    6
    listed all 12 months
    What it runs
    Results
    Account
    LuxieStays in figures
  • 9

    Serenity Housing

    #9 by listings Co-hosts on owners' accounts

    Serenity Housing runs 7 active Indianapolis Airbnb listings, and guests rate its homes 4.88 over 397 reviews.

    Active listings
    7
    Guest rating
    4.88
    397 reviews
    Rated 4.8 or higher
    100%
    of its rated homes
    Instant book
    100%
    of its listings
    What it runs
    Account
    Serenity Housing in figures
  • 10

    Grand Slam Getaways

    #10 by listings

    Grand Slam Getaways runs 6 active Indianapolis Airbnb listings, and guests rate its homes 4.74 over 379 reviews.

    Active listings
    6
    New in the past year
    Guest rating
    4.74
    379 reviews
    Instant book
    67%
    of its listings
    What it runs
    Account
    Grand Slam Getaways in figures

Checklist

Before You Sign: Seven Things to Check with an Indianapolis Manager

Benchmarks

What Indianapolis Airbnbs Earn: Benchmarks to Test a Manager's Pitch

A manager's projection is only as good as the homes it is compared with. These are the typical results for Indianapolis entire homes listed for all 12 months, by bedroom count, over the 12 months to September 2026.

What Indianapolis entire homes earned a year, by bedroom count

What Indianapolis Airbnbs Earn: Benchmarks to Test a Manager's Pitch
HomeMedianTop quarter overTo net the median after 20%
1 bedroom 491 homes$20,100$30,700$25,130
2 bedrooms 551 homes$26,900$40,300$33,630
3 bedrooms 475 homes$31,400$48,400$39,250
4 bedrooms 222 homes$47,600$70,400$59,500
5+ bedrooms 111 homes$78,500$113,000$98,130

Booking revenue of entire homes listed all 12 months. A quarter of homes earned less than the bottom-quarter figure and a quarter more than the top-quarter one. The last column is what a home has to earn for a 20% fee to leave its owner the median.

A projection above the top-quarter line for your size of home ($40,300 for a two-bedroom) should come with the comparable homes the company already runs. The fee changes the sum: on a two-bedroom earning the median $26,900, a 20% fee comes to $5,380 a year and leaves its owner $21,520, so to leave you with the median a manager has to bring in $33,630.

Before comparing managers' fees, see what the home itself could earn: the Airbnb estimator gives a revenue range for one Indianapolis address from comparable listings.

Estimate what your Indianapolis home could earn

Market structure

Who Runs Indianapolis's Airbnb Market

Hosts with a single listing run 32% of Indianapolis's Airbnbs. Accounts with 20 or more listings, companies, individuals and hotels alike, run 20%. These bands count Airbnb accounts, not brands, so a company with several accounts can sit in more than one. The share Airbnb flags as professionally managed rose from 12% to 15% over the year.

Accounts with 20 or more listings run 20% of Indianapolis's Airbnbs

Share of Indianapolis's 2,990 active listings, by how many listings their operator runs in the city

  • Hosts with one listing 32% · 950 operators
  • 2–4 listings 25% · 311 operators
  • 5–19 listings 23% · 96 operators
  • 20–99 listings 16% · 15 operators
  • 100 or more 4% · 1 operators

36% of Indianapolis's listings name at least one co-host. Many management companies work that way: the listing, its reviews and its payouts stay on the owner's account, and the company runs it as co-host. The profiles above show how much of each company's portfolio runs on owners' accounts. Airbnb's own "professional host" flag covers 15% of listings; it marks hosts who run several homes, companies or not, so it isn't the same measure as the company share.

Where they work

Where Indianapolis's Management Companies Operate

The share of each neighborhood's active listings run by management companies and other business accounts.

Where Indianapolis's Management Companies Operate
NeighborhoodActive listingsShare run by companies
ZIP 4620428230%
ZIP 462252535%
ZIP 462022356%
ZIP 462011355%
ZIP 462051309%
ZIP 462201287%
ZIP 4620610618%
ZIP 462081009%
ZIP 4628210046%
ZIP 46203847%

Neighborhood · active listings · share run by management companies and other businesses

Rules

Rules a Indianapolis Manager Has to Follow

The rules follow the property, whoever runs it. Short-term renting in Indianapolis is allowed you can host on Airbnb in Indianapolis with a city short-term rental permit that costs $150 once and renews free every year.

The Indianapolis Airbnb regulations page covers the permit, fees, operating limits and taxes, each linked to its official source. A manager that takes on your home should handle the permit and tax filings, and the contract should say who does what.

Indianapolis Airbnb regulations Permit, fees, limits and taxes

FAQ

Indianapolis Airbnb Management: Frequently Asked Questions

What is the largest Airbnb management company in Indianapolis?

CozySuites runs 161 active Indianapolis Airbnb listings, more than any other company in AirROI's data for the 12 months to September 2026, ahead of LiveSuites (46) and Evolve (44).

How many Airbnb management companies operate in Indianapolis?

In the 12 months to September 2026, 5 management companies ran 10 or more active Indianapolis listings, and 12 ran 5 or more. Many smaller managers work as co-hosts on owners' accounts; they are counted on every listing they co-host.

What share of Indianapolis Airbnbs are professionally managed?

Airbnb's own "professional host" flag, which also covers individuals who run several homes, is on 15%, against 12% a year earlier. 36% list at least one co-host.

Do professionally managed Airbnbs earn more in Indianapolis?

Yes, on average. In the 12 months to September 2026, Indianapolis homes run by companies with 10 or more listings earned 14% more than owner-run homes with the same number of bedrooms and room type (138 company-run and 262 owner-run year-round homes), according to AirROI. Company-run homes also charge 16% more a night than owner-run homes of the same size. Managers also choose which homes they take on, so part of any gap reflects the homes themselves.

Is it worth hiring an Airbnb manager in Indianapolis?

It can be, with the right company. 46% of company-run Indianapolis homes earned 25% or more above the owner-run median for their size, enough to cover a 20% fee, against 33% of owner-run homes with no manager. A manager also buys back the time hosting takes: guest messages, cleaning, pricing and upkeep.

How much do Airbnb management companies charge in Indianapolis?

Few management companies publish their fees. Of the 81 companies AirROI checked in 6 US cities in September 2026, 9 publish a rate, from 10% to 30% of booking revenue with a median starting rate of 15%, and 49 quote only on request. So ask each Indianapolis company for its rate in writing, and whether it's a share of nightly revenue only or of cleaning fees too. What a fee has to earn is fixed: a 20% fee needs a 25% lift in revenue to leave you where you started, and a 30% fee needs 43%.

How much does a 2-bedroom Airbnb make in Indianapolis?

The median 2-bedroom entire home in Indianapolis earned $26,900 in the 12 months to September 2026, and the top quarter earned $40,300 or more, at a median 40% occupancy.

Which Indianapolis Airbnb management companies have the best guest ratings?

Among Indianapolis management companies with at least 10 rated listings and 100 reviews, Lazy Sunday Rentals (4.89), Evolve (4.72) and LiveSuites (4.70) had the highest average guest ratings in the 12 months to September 2026.

Which Airbnb management companies are growing fastest in Indianapolis?

CozySuites (+36 listings), LiveSuites (+9 listings), Evolve (+7 listings) added the most listings on their own Airbnb accounts over the past year.

What is an Airbnb co-host, and how common are they in Indianapolis?

A co-host helps run a listing that stays on the owner's Airbnb account, from messaging guests to pricing and cleaning, so the listing, its reviews and its payouts stay with the owner if the manager changes. A listing on a company's own account belongs to the company, and its reviews usually don't move with the home. 36% of Indianapolis's active listings name at least one co-host, and several of the companies above run most of their homes that way.

Do I need a permit if a company manages my Indianapolis Airbnb?

Yes: the rules apply to the property whoever runs it. Short-term renting in Indianapolis is allowed you can host on Airbnb in Indianapolis with a city short-term rental permit that costs $150 once and renews free every year. The Indianapolis Airbnb regulations page has the permit steps, fees and taxes.

How are these Indianapolis management companies ranked?

By the number of active Indianapolis Airbnb listings each company runs, as host or co-host, in the 12 months to September 2026. Individual hosts who don't trade as a business are not named.

Method

How This Ranking Works

The ranking counts active Airbnb listings in Indianapolis over the 12 months to September 2026, on the same definition as AirROI's Indianapolis market report, so the totals match. A listing counts toward its host account and toward every co-host named on it, because many companies run homes on the owner's own account. A company that runs several Airbnb accounts under one brand appears once, with the accounts combined.

The full method: classification, comparisons and fees

Accounts are classified from their names, and the Indianapolis accounts with the most listings were checked by hand. Only property-management businesses are ranked, under the name they trade as; individual hosts who don't trade as a business count in every market figure but are never named, and neither are accounts with a generic name, such as "Property" or "Concierge", that can't be tied to a company. Hotels and serviced-apartment operators that list their own rooms are left out, and so are companies that mostly take stays of a month or more, because they compete with rentals rather than holiday lets.

"Lead vs similar" compares each of a company's homes with the median owner-run Indianapolis home of the same bedroom count and room type, and reports the median of those comparisons. The figure is shown where a company's homes earn more than similar ones. A lower figure isn't shown: on Airbnb data alone it mostly reflects listings that are new or re-listed and still building reviews, or homes that differ in ways a bedroom count misses, rather than the management. Only homes listed for the whole 12 months and open to bookings on at least 240 nights, booked on 60 or more, with 5 or more reviews count, on both sides, so a company that added homes mid-year isn't marked down for their short first year, a listing that sits idle or is too new to have reviews doesn't stand for its company, and an owner who rents out their own home a few weekends a year doesn't set the benchmark. Companies with fewer than five such homes show a dash, and those with fewer than ten show "few": too few to compare fairly, so their figures are never quoted. The ranking by revenue needs at least 15. The shortlist by home size needs five homes of a size and marks a figure on fewer than ten as a small sample. The ± bands treat homes as independent; homes run by one company resemble each other, so the true uncertainty is somewhat wider. The profiles split revenue into revenue per booked night and nights booked, on the same homes, each against the owner-run median for that measure. A home's revenue is the one times the other, but the three medians don't multiply: among owner-run homes, the ones that charge more tend to book fewer nights, so the median rate times the median nights isn't the median revenue. A company's rating averages its listings' overall Airbnb ratings, weighted by their reviews. Revenue is gross Airbnb booking revenue, estimated from booked nights and rates, before any management fee. Stays a company or owner sells on other sites or direct aren't counted, so a company that sells much of its calendar elsewhere can look weaker here than it is; that applies to owner-run homes too. A home counts toward the company named on it now, so a home that changed manager during the year brings months run by its previous one.

The fee figures pool the rates management companies publish on their own websites, checked by hand in September 2026 in the 6 US cities AirROI researched. No company's rate is shown on its own: most quote each home on request, so the page gives the spread of the published rates instead.

Growth counts the listings a company hosts on its own Airbnb accounts now against 12 months earlier. Companies that mostly co-host on owners' accounts show no growth figure, because Airbnb's co-host records from a year ago are incomplete, and accounts with no listings a year ago are marked new rather than ranked for growth.

The page is rebuilt each quarter from the latest listing data. A company that thinks its figures are wrong can write to AirROI, and corrections are checked against the listing data.